Suicide Silence - Ending is the Beginning: The Mitch Lucker Memorial Show - (8.5/10)

Published on March 4, 2014

Tracklist:

  1. Destruction Of A Statue (Jonny Davy, Job For A Cowboy)
  2. Distorted Thought Of Addiction (Greg Wilborn, The Devastated)
  3. Ending Is The Beginning (Brook Reeves, Impending Doom)
  4. Bludgeoned To Death (Ricky Hoover, ex-Suffokate)
  5. Unanswered (Phil Bozeman, Whitechapel)
  6. Girl Of Glass (Myke Terry, ex-Bury Your Dead)
  7. The Price Of Beauty (Danny Worsop, Asking Alexandria)
  8. No Pity For A Coward (Johnny Plague, Winds Of Plague)
  9. Disengage (Cameron "Big Chocolate" Argon, Disfiguring The Goddess)
  10. No Time To Bleed (Burke Varaalte, With Dead Hands Rising)
  11. Smoke (Anthony Notarmaso, After The Burial)
  12. Wake Up (Tim Lambesis, As I Lay Dying)
  13. March Of The Black Crown
  14. Slaves To Substance (Eddie Hermida, ex-All Shall Perish)
  15. OCD (Austin Carlisle, Of Mice And Men)
  16. Fuck Everything (Chad Gray, Mudvayne, Hellyeah)
  17. Die Young (Robb Flynn, Machine Head)
  18. Roots Bloody Roots (Max Cavalera, ex-Sepultura, Soulfly)
  19. Engine #9 (Mitch Lucker Vocal Track)
  20. You Only Live Once (Randy Blythe, Lamb Of God)

Genre:

Deathcore / Death

Label:

Century Media Records

Playing Time:

1:13:18

Country:

U.S.A

Year:

2014

Website:

Visit page

 

 

Suicide Silence are, without doubt, the biggest export the genre has produced.1, 2  They were one of the genre’s earliest flag bearers and over a career spanning three critically acclaimed albums (the highlight being 2009’s No Time To Bleed) have grown and evolved into one of not only deathcore’s best, but a band deservedly at the forefront of modern metal in general. A large3 part of the band’s success and appeal had to do with vocalist Mitch Lucker, for whom Suicide Silence’s indisputable success was cut altogether too short as a result of a fatal motorcycle accident in November of 2012. Ending Is The Beginning is a DVD/CD recording of the tribute show held for Lucker in December of 2012 (the fatal year in question), which featured a host of (predominantly deathcore) assorted metal vocalists fronting the band, from which all proceeds going towards Lucker’s daughter Kenadee’s education.

 

Screen Shot 2014-02-24 at 3.37.43 pm

“A lot of big earrings man…”

 

With the majority of vocalists understandably being sourced from the deathcore genre, most of Ending Is The Beginning’s tracks sound little distinguished from their Lucker-fronted renditions – the DVD’s title only giving each vocalist’s name and the track they’re performing, neglecting to mention which band(s) they’re from – which is to say it is no surprise that Job For A Cowboy’s Jonny Davy (who opens things up with, usual Suicide Silence closer, “Destruction Of A Statue”) or Phil Bozman of Whitechapelcan slip appropriately into Lucker’s shoes (as it proverbially were), and which, depending on how you look at it, gives credence to the argument either that all death metal/hardcore vocalists are essentially indistinct and (thus) interchangeable or otherwise (or perhaps concurrently) that given vocalists are of such a caliber that they are able to rise comfortably to the occasion and high standard set by Lucker to great result.

 

Of course, of immediate note and intrigue is that Ending Is The Beginning provides, to this point, the only recording of new/current-Suicide-Silence-now-ex-All Shall Perish singer, Eddie Hermida, with Suicide Silence4 (perhaps the “Beginning” of which the releases title speaks?), following his scandalous recruitment– to which Herminda’s performance of “Slaves To Substance” belongs to the above category; and which category, the unavoidably mustached, Cameron “Big Chocolte” Argon (a.k.a. Disfiguring The Goddess) pushes to the limit with his beyond brutal “Disengage;” and which exercise actually exposes Winds Of Plague front man and certified tool Johnny Plague,5 who gets the honor of performing Suicide Silence’s signature6 song,7 as a far more capable and effective vocalist than his day job suggests.

 

 Screen Shot 2014-02-24 at 3.58.32 pm

Eddie Hemida: happiness in slavery.

 

Of far more curious intrigue and aesthetic result are those performances that don’t at once seem entirely fitting; the most removed of these being the eyebrow-raising appearance of current “malcore” poster-boys Asking Alexandria’s Danny Worsop, who delivers a startlingly competent and altogether savage performance of “The Price Of Beauty” that entertains almost as thoroughly as his Welsh-accented interjections.8 Other (more-)unlikely collaborations include ex-Bury Your Dead front man, and altogether swell dude, Myke Terry, sans dread, breaking his post-BYD (suicide) silence; the tonally distinct performance of Austin Carlisle of Attack Attack-come-Of Mice And Men fame and Chad Gray pleasant retching of “Fuck Everything” – the brutal backdrop sounding altogether more akin to his work with the dissolved Mudvayne than the red-meat-and-no-potatoes fare of his current outfit, Hellyeah

 

Screen Shot 2014-02-24 at 4.07.37 pm

Chad Gray: Getting his “fuck” on.

 

Beginning Is The End’s most unexpected comes in the form of a cover of the Dio-era Black Sabbath track “Die Young,” fronted by Machine Head’s Robb Flynn (along with Suicide Silence guitarist Mark Heylmun and… a roadie?) which provides Ending Is The Beginning with its most emotionally touching moment and its undeniable best for those, like your reviewer, who never fail to get shivers at the aural ingestion of Flynn’s voice. “Die Young” is followed by two other cover songs: a Max Cavalera-fronted “Roots Bloody Roots,” which, really hammers home just how much Roots and that song in particular has had on modern metal; and, Deftones classic-come-Suicided Silence staple,“Engine #9,”9 bizarrely not sung by Deftones’ Chino Moreno,10 but is instead overdubbed with audio of Lucker himself, which recording’s simulacrum-inducing “live” crowd work create an awkward, experience for the listener, with the DVD’s splicing of video footage faring marginally better while still creating the same existential (and slightly more epileptic) discomfort.

 

 Screen Shot 2014-02-24 at 4.09.47 pm

I’m really sorry if that’s like someone really famous and, like, totally not a roadie.

 

At the risk of (further) critiquing a compelling tribute to a tragically dead comrade of all involved, there are a few moments during Ending Is The Beginning that come off unconsidered or otherwise unbefitting. There is of course the involvement of, As I Lay Dying front man, Tim Lambesis, who, while nothing but the perceived bastion of decency and goodwill at the time of recording Ending Is The Beginning, has since been remanded and is currently undergoing trial for the attempted murder of his estranged(ex-?) wife by means of the fictional hitman “Red,” who was actually an undercover police officer to which Lambesis has pleaded guilty (his only defense being the foreseeably feeble one of “roid-rage”) – which can’t be said to have any connection to Ending Is The Beginning or Suicide Silence, et al., but still shines an awkward and uncomfortable light on what is meant to be an earnest celebration of life – let alone the troubling fact that his (Lambesis’s) performance reminds us that he’s rather good at what he does.

 

 maxresdefault

Mitch Lucker, a few days before his death.

 

More directly unsettling is After The Burial’s Anthony Notarmaso’s announcing “Smoke” with the call “from one straightedge guy to you… to reach into your pocket and grab that bag of weed and fire up right now… everybody smoke fucking weed” (sic.), which, again, while I’m sure is of innocent sentiment and intention, is beyond unsettling given that Lucker’s death was tied up with/resultant of alcohol abuse, of which Lucker’s widow, Jolie, had this to say:

 

He (Lucker) was an alcoholic, and it’s been a big battle. I tried to stop him. I was in front of him begging him not to leave the house. Begging him. Like, ‘Just seriously, for us, don’t leave.’ And he did… and he’s gonna miss out on watching Kenadee grow because he decided to drink and drive. Just don’t, just think before you guys do something stupid, please learn from it. Please.” (sic.)

 

Add to this the issue of the crowd being more or less entirely made up of sixteen-year-olds (which the DVD’s introduction shows are quite the impressionable sort) and this seems like a very strange position to take indeed given Notarmaso’s personal, and proclaimed, straight edge stance.

 

Screen Shot 2014-02-24 at 5.38.25 pm 

Seriously, is anyone at this show over 18??

 

Likewise is Randy Blythe’s commanding “You only live once, so just go fucking nuts” and encouraged chant of “Live life hard” as the Lamb Of God front man and modern-metal behemoth closes out the show with “You Only Live Once” (Flynn on the electric guitar now), which all seems entirely appropriate on paper – and, again, I’m sure is best-intentioned – but nonetheless is provocative of a dark light given the circumstances of Lucker’s death, which I’ll reiterate involved substance abuse, which left his wife a widow and his daughter fatherless. And I’ll preempt responses, “not to politicize a man’s death” (and the subsequent tribute to that man’s life), by reminding the reader that personal actions are necessarily (through self-endorsement) political actions and, as much as it is good to celebrate Lucker’s life and achievements, his tragic11 death should also be heeded and learned from, which your reviewer submits is in fact the greatest celebration of Lucker’s life: to learn from it and take into account its preservation; which sentiment is supported by his wife in the above quote.12

 

 Screen Shot 2014-02-24 at 5.46.17 pm

Bringing it on home: Randy Blythe has lived harder than most.

 

This sour end-note aside, Ending is The Beginning is a marvelous celebration of Lucker’s life and a first-class reminder of why Suicide Silence is at the forefront of their nominal pack. As a catalogue-spanning collection of songs, and thus a showcase of what Suicide Silence are all about, Ending Is The Beginning is unfaultable and undeniable – a sentiment which translates to the rest of the band’s performance and reiterates their own power as a live force (see “No Time To Bleed”). Besides the contentious qualms discussed above, Ending Is The Beginning’s only drawback is its lack of in-between-song interaction, and hence lack of introduction for each vocalist, who (as mentioned) can at times tend to be indistinguishable and/or not immediately recognizable. Regardless of its aesthetic wealth however, Ending Is The Beginning is a (near-)perfect testament to Lucker, a metal legend, who (in a most-sincere form of irony), although gone, is not and will never be silenced.

 

 

 

Donations to the Kenadee Lucker Education fund can be made through the band’s official website:13 http://www.suicidesilence.net/

 

Mitch Lucker

Mitch Lucker: Gone but definitely not forgotten.

 

NOTE ON THE CRITIQUE AND RATING: It does not escape your reviewer that, on top of being a product and an artwork, up for evaluation, Ending Is The Beginning is first and foremost an actual and very personal tribute to Mitch Lucker, and that despite assertions about the nature of personal politics in the body of the review he respects the nature and sentiment of what is actually being reviewed here and only does so out of promotion and reaction to something he has very much connected with and enjoyed. Your reviewer also recognizes that giving the recording a rating is entirely inappropriate in the context of the tribute itself and stresses that such rating and critical analysis he has provided applies only to Ending Is The Beginning the product, not to the (acknowledged) very personal sentiment of everyone involved – to which the application of such qualitative ratings would be highly insensitive, let alone nonsensical. Your Reviewer means no disrespect to Lucker or any of those involved by anything he has said here14 nor does he seek to trivialize the matter with the excessive amounts of (mostly jestful) footnotes he has employed here, which footnotes ontop of being part of own artistic growth and expression he finds rather amusing. Rest in peace Mitch, and thank you for the sweet tunes.

 

 

_______________

1 As in most popular, not some kind of mass-defined assessment that would favor the likes of Crowbar and Eyehategod should the categorization be applied to the sludge genre,1(a) which if not obvious from the context is at least derivable from the premise that Mitch Lucker, let alone other (questionable; see FN2) deathcore front men, was frequently lampooned for his smaller stature.

1(a) Crowbar being heavily (see above disclaimer) favored in both hypothetical categories.

2 Bring Me The Horizon having been deemed here to have both outgrown/transcended the “deathcore” label.

3 Here the relevant definition refuted in FN1 being entirely, albeit analogously, appropriate and correct.

4Well, besides this.

5 Well not actually certifiably certifiable, but the dude goes by the name “Plague” in a band by the name “Plague,” so there certainly seems to be at least grounds for certification. And then there’s always the backwards fitted cap to go by.

6 And admittedly uncomfortably misogynistic and unsympathetic yet (even more admittedly) undeniably catchy.

7 #MadAlliterationSkillz

8 If you don’t find metal bands talking in Welsh accents to be highly amusing I encourage you to watch any of Bullet For My Valentine’s live banter and strongly reconsider your position.

9 True fact: Not all pedophiles dislike the Deftones, but everyone who doesn’t like the Deftones is a pedophile.

10 One wonders about this for a second and then remembers scheduling and prior commitments and geography are a thing.

11 I tried really hard not to use this word but there it is.

12 Admittedly “live life cautiously and responsibly” doesn’t quite have the same ring too it, unless you’re The Lonely Island.

13 Indeed, that’s all that can be done through the band’s official website.

14 Well, except for the whole Johnny Plague is a certifiable tool thing, which (there really is no escaping) is disrespectful to the named party and inappropriate in the context. Your reviewer apologizes for this disrespect (though not the essence of the comment, which your reviewer stands by, on the basis that Winds Of Plague’s last record, Resistance (2013), was so unbearably dumb that he’d feel he was doing himself a disrespect not to say something on the matter).

 

Joshua Bulleid

Author: Joshua Bulleid

2 thoughts on “Suicide Silence – Ending is the Beginning: The Mitch Lucker Memorial Show

  1. Pingback: SINGLES ROUNDUP: May 9th 2014. | The Metal Observer

  2. Pingback: When Death And Death Metal Collide: A TMO Interview With Mark Heylmun | The Metal Observer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *